מותר ברוטב ובקיפה, ורבי יהודה אוסר.
is permitted to eat gravy and sediments of boiled meat [kifa]. But R' Yehuda maintains that he is prohibited from eating them.
Study Nedarim folio 52A with parallel Hebrew-English text, traditional commentary, and modern study tools. Free access to Babylonian Talmud online.
מותר ברוטב ובקיפה, ורבי יהודה אוסר.
is permitted to eat gravy and sediments of boiled meat [kifa]. But R' Yehuda maintains that he is prohibited from eating them.
אמר רבי יהודה: מעשה ואסר עלינו רבי טרפון בביצים שנתבשלו עמו. אמרו לו: כן הדבר, אימתי — בזמן שיאמר: ״בשר זה עלי״, שהנודר מן הדבר ונתערב באחר, אם יש בו בנותן טעם — אסור.
R' Yehuda said: There was an incident where one took such a vow and R' Tarfon prohibited us from even eggs that were cooked with meat. The Rabbis said to him: Indeed so, but when is this the halakha? When he says: This meat is forbidden to me, referring to a specific piece of meat. This is because in the case of one who vows that an item is forbidden to him, and it becomes mixed into another item, if the latter contains an amount of the forbidden food that gives it flavor, i.e., the forbidden food can be tasted in the permitted food, the mixture is forbidden. However, if one vows that meat in general is forbidden to him, without specifying a particular piece, only the meat itself is forbidden, not the gravy, sediments, or eggs cooked with that meat.
הנודר מן היין — מותר בתבשיל שיש בו טעם יין. אמר: ״קונם יין זה שאני טועם״ ונפל לתבשיל, אם יש בו בנותן טעם — הרי זה אסור.
Likewise, one who vows that wine is forbidden to him is permitted to eat a cooked dish that has the flavor of wine. However, if he said: This wine is konam for me, and for that reason I will not taste it, and the wine fell into a cooked dish, if the dish contains an amount of the wine that gives it flavor, it is forbidden.
Text data via Sefaria: William Davidson Edition - English and William Davidson Edition - Vocalized Aramaic, CC-BY-NC; edition provenance: Koren. Display terminology has been modernized for readability.